“die-and-retry” Games

1. Elden Ring

PS5PS4steamXbox

Elden Ring takes FromSoftware's Soulslike combat into an open world designed by Hidetaka Miyazaki and George R.R. Martin. The Legacy Dungeons preserve the dense, interconnected level design of earlier entries while the Lands Between rewards patient exploration. GPA scores it at 95% for both Difficulty and Action — the highest Action score in the database.

2. Dark Souls III

PS4steamXbox

Dark Souls III accelerates the series' pacing and sharpens its boss design into its most refined form. The lore runs through item descriptions and environmental detail rather than cutscenes. GPA scores it at 90% for both Difficulty and Lore Focus — two axes that define the experience more precisely than genre alone.

3. Hollow Knight

Nintendo SwitchPS5PS4steamXbox

Hollow Knight puts a silent knight in a vast underground insect kingdom built with hand-drawn art and a score that shifts by region. The map system withholds information until it's earned. GPA scores it at the top for Difficulty and Action among platformers, with Dark World running high — a combination that points at players who want atmosphere alongside the mechanical challenge.

4. Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice

PS5PS4steamXbox

Sekiro removes the build customization of the Souls series and replaces it with a deflection-based combat system where reading enemy attacks is the only viable approach. GPA scores it at maximum Difficulty — the highest in the database alongside Cuphead — with Action close behind.

5. Nioh 2

PS5PS4steam

Nioh 2 builds its samurai action around the Soul Core system and a Yokai Shift transformation that temporarily unlocks a second move set. The Burst Counter mechanic rewards reading specific enemy attacks. GPA scores it high on Action and Difficulty — the combination that places it in the Soulslike cluster while the transformation system provides a mechanical layer Dark Souls entries lack.

6. Demon's Souls

PS5

Demon's Souls was FromSoftware's proof of concept for the Soulslike format, and the PS5 remake preserves the original's structure in high fidelity. The World Tendency system changes enemy behavior based on in-game actions. GPA scores it high on Difficulty and Dark World — the combination that defines the series' origin point.

7. Hades

Nintendo SwitchPS5PS4steam

Hades follows Zagreus through escape attempts from the underworld where story advances regardless of success or failure. GPA scores it at the top for Roguelike and high on Action, with Emotional Story above 70.

8. Dark Souls Remastered

Nintendo SwitchPS4steamXbox

Dark Souls Remastered brings the 2011 original to PS4, Xbox One, Switch, and PC with improved frame rate and netcode, including the Artorias of the Abyss DLC. QLOC handled the remaster. FromSoftware's world-building through item descriptions and environmental layout remains the genre benchmark. GPA scores it at the top for Difficulty and Dark World — the Soulslike origin point that established the vocabulary all successors use.

9. Dark Souls II Scholar of the First Sin

PS4steamXbox

Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin packages all three DLC chapters and rearranges enemy placements and NPC questlines from the original release. The HP degradation mechanic on death distinguishes it from the other FromSoftware entries. PS3, PS4, Xbox 360, Xbox One, PC. GPA scores it high on Difficulty and Dark World — the Dark Souls entry that most rewards NPC questline investment.

10. Mortal Shell

Nintendo SwitchPS5PS4steamXbox

Mortal Shell builds its Soulslike around Shell possession — inhabiting the bodies of fallen warriors with distinct combat styles — and a Harden mechanic that turns the player into a statue to absorb one attack. Cold Symmetry's debut. Switch, PS4/5, Xbox, PC. GPA scores it high on Action and Dark World — the indie Soulslike that delivered a distinct mechanical identity without the FromSoftware budget.

11. Hellpoint

Nintendo SwitchPS5PS4steamXbox

Hellpoint places its Soulslike combat on a Irid Novo station orbiting a black hole, with a clock system that cycles difficulty based on orbital position. Local split-screen co-op distinguishes it from most genre entries. Cradle Games, tinyBuild. Switch, PS4/5, Xbox, PC. GPA scores it high on Action and Dark World — the SF-setting Soulslike that pairs the genre's hostility with space horror atmosphere.

12. The Surge 2

PS4steamXbox

The Surge 2 expands Deck13's limb-targeting system into Jericho City, letting players sever specific enemy body parts to loot their gear. The combat rewards precision over stat investment. Focus Entertainment. PS4, Xbox One, PC. GPA scores it high on Action and Strategy — the Soulslike where the dismemberment mechanic is inseparable from the loot economy.